 |
|
This event became a popular
subject of the European painters--each successive painting being more fanciful
than the last. Even Webber, artist with the expedition, took license with the
event. His oil painting, done after his return to England, depicts Cook dressed
up for the event in formal breeches and hose, whereas an earlier sketch showed
him wearing the more customary canvas trousers. Webber painted Cook being
attacked while standing on a sandy beach; but Cook was struck down while
striding toward the water across a broad shelf of lava.
This painting
is an attempt to reconstruct the moment more accurately. It is based on the
accounts of those who were present, a study of the weapons and dress of both
sides, and estimates by scientists of the physical setting.
In this
painting may be the first depiction of the Hawaiian battle mat. British
journals refer to the bulky protective mats worn by Hawaiian warriors, but
there are no existing mats, or drawings showing how they were fashioned and
worn. The best clue was found in Lt. King's statement that these were worn in
the same manner as the feather capes, and both Kink and Clerke described the
feather capes as battle apparel.
Knowing that in close combat the cape
was shifted from behind and carried over the left shoulder, with the bulk of
the cape held foward by the left hand to take the impact of a sling stone or to
snag the point of a spear or dagger, and leaving the right shoulder and arm
exposed and free to wield a weapon, we may assume that the battle mat was worn
the smae way.
Geologists believe that this coastline has subsided 28
inches in the last 200 years. The rock from which Cook fell is now submerged,
but one may still locate it and study it through a diver's mask.
Marine Lt. Molesworth Phillips heard Cook's last shout, but then lost sight of
Cook in the confusion. He was struck down and stabbed in the shoulder, but
managed to raise himself and fire at his assailant before escaping. Witnesses
saw a man with a fencepost or crude club strike Cook behind the head, while a
chief in a feather cape rushed around a parked double canoe and stabbed him
with one of the iron daggers the ship's blacksmiths had been forging as trade
items.
This man was known to the British as "Nua" (probably Kanuha),
a close relative of the king, who Surgeon's Mate Samwell described as a chief
of "...great consequence ...tall and stout and one who united in his figure
the two qualities of strength and agility in a greater degree, than I ever
remembered to have seen before in any other man." Cook fell. Face down in
the water, he was stabbed many times.
In the painting, at the far
left, the old king is being taken away to safety. The boy fleeing in the
foreground represents the king's son who happened to be sitting in one of the
boats when the fracas began. The marine corporal, James Thomas, is depicted
waist deep in the water, receiving a mortal wound from a dagger thrust.
Resolution is shown with the foremast removed; it had been hoisted out and
taken to the beach at the other side of the bay for repair.
Cook's
hand was raised toward the boats. This gesture has been widely interpreted as a
signal to his men to cease firing. However, J.C. Beaglehole, the most eminent
of Cook scholars, found no justification for this belief. Cook was waving to
the boats to come in closer to shore. Like so many mariners of his day, he
could not swim.
Page 87, Voyagers